i want to know does a thin karateist can defeat a huge... - Baseball, Basketball, Hockey, Football, Rugby, Cricket, Tennis, Formula One, WWE, IRL, NHL, MLB, NFL, NBA, PGA, NASCAR

unknown1 u · #1 (**permalink**) 04-05-2007, 06:45 PM

...human? many times age i tried to learn karate because i really needed it and not for sport, rather for defeating my same age bad students.

but i want to know which if these two human with the following feature can defeat other?

1- a 175cm, 55kg, 17 years old, experienced in karate man
but not very strong.

2- a 180cm, 100kg, 18 years old, not experienced in karate man but strong.

Thanks.

tonette · #2 (**permalink**) 04-05-2007, 07:45 PM

of course. it's where you will deliver the blow to your opponents body that will cripple him. in karate, your master will show you a diagram of a human body and points where to deliver a deadly blow. the master will also show you some points in a human body where to deliver a blow that will knock down your opponent. so it's not the force or the strenght of your body. it's where you land the blow to your opponents body. you'd better not get yourself into trouble now. karate should be coupled with strict discipline. don't hurt anyone.

Hamza Hashem · #3 (**permalink**) 04-05-2007, 08:55 PM

Any size can defeat any other size. It depends on training and application. If you trained Karate, but it does not come to you as reflexes, that is, if you are still thinking about what to do, it is likely you will not hold a significant advantage. Size can be an advantage/disadvantage depending on whom you are. You have to know how to utilize your strengths against another?s weakness (That is why fighters train before they fight).

While this can be done, the better question lies in, why do you need to fight? A strong mind and spirit can stand against anyone and find alternative solutions to confrontation. Fighting should be your last option.

hupfzwerg · #4 (**permalink**) 04-05-2007, 09:00 PM

It gives many points on the Human body that can crash the strongest man. one of them is the Solar plexus if u hit this point it take the breath from the other, he looses control and further able to fight. the second point are his Balls, hit him there and he cries like a baby.
You need technique, Speed and no fear
Learn how to fight to, avoid a fight...it sounds crazy, but it´s the only way

gojuryukaratedo · #5 (**permalink**) 04-05-2007, 09:55 PM

Karate just helps. Think of it as an equalizer. There are so many factors to a fight.

Speed, Strength, Endurance, Experience, Tactics, Techniques, and the list goes on and on.

Karate should help provide you with Tactics and Techniques.

It may provide you some exercise that will help you with the attributes of Speed, Strength, and Endurance.

Depending on the type of controlled fighting you do, you "might" be able to consider that some form of "experience", but that's a stretch.

So, the person with the best complete set of factors is likely to survive the fight.